Make this my home page
More buttons
Best of the Day
Page
Paid Parental Leave - all the other kids are doing it
Video

I Google Myself - looking for sex and love online

Blog
Sync or Swim - Olympic Sychronized Swimming
Game
Final Fantasy XIII
Art
Julie Heffernan - the gorgeous and the grotesque
Cool tools
Hot links
Exposing systematic torture in Iran
Museum of science fiction, utopia and extraordinary journeys
The real story of christianity
Image bookmarking
Developing tech to get the internet to its full potential
Free Culture, Open Government, Liberty
Online Buddhist meditation
Reducing harm from drug use
The community is the brand
Dissecting the {Subset} Culture
Catching a lift to the heavens
A comprehensive look at the Iraq war
Internet news for the masses
The social music revolution
A fresh Australian gaming site.
Art as Sacred Cow

Art is a fragile adolescent creature in Australia. It is constantly threatened with extinction, its habitat polluted by grandstanding politicians and the censorship of those ordinary citizens who, as Hitler once opined, enjoy a ‘healthy taste of art’.

But psychotherapist RENATE OGILVIE questions if art should therefore be turned into a Sacred Cow, exempt from cultural analysis.

Why is it that we bemoan the ghastly sexualisation of children and adolescents in our late capitalist culture, but piously draw the curtain on art? Is this a fallback to the 19th century, where closet gays would hang up the celebrated S&M image of St Sebastian, bound and pierced by arrows, on the pretence that this was simply an artistic image?

Surely we accept that there has always been a knowingness about art, an ambivalence of artistic and aesthetic meaning blended with a much more robust message. So why not look at the latter without tying ourselves up in knots, no pun intended, as we feel duty bound to stem the philistine hordes.

Art is about a personal response to reality being filtered through a particularly consciousness. Bellmer's dolls don't make me feel particularly uplifted, while Anselm Kiefer moves me, and some of Bonnard's sumptuous post-coital interiors, well, please me.

I find Henson's images of adolescents disturbing, and interestingly, so do most of my female friends. Rightly or wrongly, we sense a male predatory gaze - not just his, but also of those who will pay for his images. That is a personal response to Henson's art which does not need to be justified.

The question is: should Messrs Plod arrive and close the exhibition down because some of us feels this way, and should a judge be asked to evaluate artistic merit? That is even more disturbing. It brings back iconic images of the Monty Python judge in red underpants being whipped in the interval of an obscenity trial, and Richard Neville standing up in his crocheted vest in court, defending himself against a barbaric prison sentence.

The Buddha teaches us that all cognised objects are experienced individually, that there is no absolute, only relative reality, and that we are constantly deluded in our interpretation of it. It makes judgment of any kind extremely problematical.

While some see sex as a relatively harmless pursuit - perhaps a Swedish model of physical exercise, others experience it as a deadly serious pursuit, with an emphasis on deadly. One things is certain: we are all fascinated by it, and there is a vague consensus that not absolutely everything goes. Or does it?

Stifled by the prudery of the 50's, my generation of baby boomers were tempted to think why not? And so we inadvertently opened the floodgates. Our sexual revolution was being warmly welcomed and exploited by liberal capitalism, and now we find ourselves uncomfortably in the middle of being new conservatives on the one hand, while at the same time still fighting the old censorship battles on the other, as the waves of hardcore and child pornography close over our heads.

We are living in times of over stimulation. Our restless monkey mind wants to be distracted and entertained: ever more extreme reality shows, hardcore porn, excesses of food, drink, drugs. The result is saturation, exhaustion, cynicism, despair. Our art reflects that, either consciously as a message, or implicitly by the extreme images it produces.

If we worry about our own mind, we should be even more concerned about the minds of our children. They need to be protected as much as possible, not from their fathers taking pictures of them at the beach, but from the leering Medusa gaze of capitalism which turns everything into money, art included.

Renate Ogilvie is a psychotherapist and teacher of Buddhist philosophy.

Go back to previous pageLeave some feedbackPrint this pageEmail link to friendsBookmark in del.icio.usAdd to Stumble ThisAdd to your favourite bookmarksDigg this article

Tags

 

Related Stories

   
Next
It's said that Russia's response to Georgia's attack on South Ossetia is disproportionate: we hear of "Western leaders anxiously watching for a withdrawal and puzzling over how to punish Moscow for what they called a disproportionate reaction to the Georgian offensive". No one has asked whether a disproportionate reaction or response is always wrong.

War, or an armed attack, can itself be a disproportionate response to some offense. If Britain, for example, declared war on Sweden for producing Abba, that would be disproportionate. It would also be wrong, because Abba isn't cause enough for initiating violence. Britain could at least ask for a large indemnity first. The Nuremberg tribunals placed aggression, a "crime against peace", ahead of war crimes. Perhaps this was meant to remind us that wars usher in far worse than war-fevered cheerleaders suppose, and are virtually always an immoral and disproportionate response to offences...

There is also a relationship between war as an immorally disproportionate response, or starting war for the wrong reasons, and all its consequences. When you start a war for the wrong reasons, you are responsible for all that follows, even the other side's atrocities. Though the other side is to blame for its crimes, so are you. You don't even have the right to kill in self-defense. If you are wrong to start a war, you don't suddenly fall into the right just because, contrary to your expectations, it's you, not the other guy, who has to defend himself.

War is not like self-defense in civilian life, when the response must be proportionate to the threat... The unacceptably disproportionate response was Georgia's in starting the war, not Russia's in finishing it. [More]

Find out about our Widget

Feedback

10 aug

The HomepageDAILY community likes to co-create both content and process. What are you thinking right now about what we do and how we do it? Tell us about the news, videos and stories and anything else you see on HPD. What you like, what you don't like, what you'd like to see in future. Recommend a website, video or article; send us pix, new stories - share it with us and by so doing you are giving us permission to share it with the world.

Leave Feedback here

            *********************************

Re: Take Your God and Shove Him

Thank you Pat Condell, you are a secular saint. My son does not attend the religion lesson at school and was told by one of the volunteers who come in to warp the kids' minds that she was "praying for him". I want to play her, and all those other interfering busybodies, this video. In fact it's so good I think I will transcribe it and pass the text around. My faveourite bit is the end: I'm not interested, I've heard it all before and I think it's all lies - insulting, degrading nonsense that contaminates everything it touches. Whenever I'm exposed to religion I feel dirty, I feel contaminated by the mealy-mouthed platitudes that pass as wisdom, the naked money-grubbing, the controlling rhetoric devoid of any humanity or compassion, the supercilious hectoring tone, the constant intrusive demands for privilege and the absolutely unforgivable violation of the minds of young children. Amen - Michelle

            *********************************

Re: Experts Agree: Legalize Drugs - From Julian Critchley

Amen Julian Critchley. Legalize all drugs. People should have access to any molecule or compound they want. Gate Keepers for Big Pharma are costing end users a fortune. Retiring Police seniors inevitably say Legalization is the only way to take the money out of the criminal economy. Safe access through guaranteed qaulity control reduces street overdose/HIV infection. People have to have access to safe drugs on demand.

Personally I think the Olympics should be used for drug testing. The money sqaundered on the "games" and all the infrastructure around them would be better utilised in research and development. The bullshit about winners by one hundredth of a second is past a joke. Crowd control and propaganda for political posers and Patriotism "the last refuge of scoundrels". It's a farce - the athletes who do not want be used as lab rats should have drug free games which would be like the Para Olympics where the entrants display raw courage and drive with next to no support from the Public purse... Like Euthanasia, a doctor of your choice should be able to give you a legal release and advise you the best they know how about what drugs/course you wish to take. We are destroying doctors who really want to help individuals run their own lives with legal bullying by moralistic parasites who are terrified of the idea that they and all of us are responsible for our own lives - Anthony Innes

            *********************************

Re: Is Australian General Jim Molan a War Criminal?

Thanks Gerry, I did click on the link you recommended to "find the dogs" and then I threw up. Jim Molan a war crim? Generals can't help themselves. Molan bombed hospitals, Georgia bombed hospitals in Osettia. The U.S. military hasn't even faced up to its criminal obliteration of Nagasaki. War crimes are what the baddies do - it's never us - Sherbert

            *********************************

Re: Washington Comes to Mr Smith

Condi, is yet another of those on my list to post a poop to, with a note attached stating, "Take a look at yourself!" Cranky soul that I am - Dean

            *********************************

Re: Scary Mary

Love it. I have always found Julie Andrews quite frightening - Sue

9 jul
12 jun
More feedback...
© 2007 homePageDAILY - All rights reserved * Terms of Use * Privacy Policy * Advertising Information * Media Kit * Contact Us